Question

The given statement is followed by two arguments- I and II. Decide which argument(s) is/are correct for the statement.
Statement: We should plant more trees.
Argument I. Trees help in reducing pollution.
               II. Trees occupy too much of the earth's space.

• A. I is true
• B. II is true
• C. Either I or II
• D. Neither I nor II

Answer 1

The Correct Option is A

Let's analyze the statement and the given arguments to determine which argument supports the statement effectively.

Statement: We should plant more trees.

Argument I: Trees help in reducing pollution.

Argument II: Trees occupy too much of the earth's space.

Now, let's examine each argument:

1. Evaluation of Argument I:
   • Trees play a crucial role in absorbing carbon dioxide and releasing oxygen, which directly contributes to reducing air pollution. This is a well-established scientific fact.
   • Additionally, trees help in filtering pollutants by trapping dust and absorbing various harmful gases.
   • Therefore, Argument I supports the statement as it provides a valid and beneficial reason to plant more trees.
2. Evaluation of Argument II:
   • This argument suggests that trees occupy too much space, which may not contribute directly to the negative implications of planting more trees.
   • The primary concern here is about space consumption, which doesn't inherently oppose the general benefits of tree planting, such as environmental conservation and improvement.
   • Thus, Argument II does not effectively counter or provide a reason against the statement.

Conclusion: After evaluating both arguments, it is clear that Argument I is correct because it provides a substantial and beneficial reason for planting more trees. On the other hand, Argument II does not present a valid reason against tree planting.

Therefore, the correct answer is: I is true.