Question

 In the following question a statement is given followed by two arguments choose the correct option.
Statement : Should the political parties be banned
Argument I : Yes, It is necessary to teach a lesson to the politicians
Argument II : No, it will lead to an end of democracy

• A. Both the arguments are strong
• B. Neither I, nor II is strong
• C. Only I is strong
• D. Only II is strong

Answer 1

The Correct Option is D

To assess which argument is stronger regarding the statement "Should the political parties be banned?," we need to evaluate the validity and impact of each argument presented. 

1. Argument I: Yes, It is necessary to teach a lesson to the politicians.
   • This argument suggests banning political parties as a punitive measure against politicians.
   • Critically, using a blanket ban to reprimand individuals is excessive and does not address the root issues of political misconduct.
   • It does not provide a constructive solution or alternative to improve the political landscape or prevent future misconduct.
   • Therefore, Argument I is not strong as it lacks a substantial basis for improving governance or democracy.
2. Argument II: No, it will lead to an end of democracy.
   • This argument highlights a fundamental characteristic of democracy, which is the representation and choice through political parties.
   • Banning political parties would undermine democratic principles, as parties facilitate organized debate, representation, and policymaking.
   • Political parties enable citizens to align with policies and ideologies that reflect their societal values and needs.
   • Thus, Argument II is strong as it underscores the critical role of political parties in maintaining democratic integrity and structure.

Based on the evaluation of each argument, only Argument II is strong because it directly connects the consequences of banning political parties to the preservation of democratic values. Argument I fails to provide a meaningful and constructive rationale for banning political parties.