Question:
Which proposition most appropriately captures the notion of strong cultural relativism approach to Human Rights?
Which proposition most appropriately captures the notion of strong cultural relativism approach to Human Rights?
Show Hint
Strong relativism = culture mainly determines rights; universalism = rights apply to all.
Updated On: Aug 18, 2025
- Culture is the sole source of the validity of Human Right or rule
- Human Rights apply to all without any exception or restriction
- Understanding and application of Human Rights is contingent of the laws made in each jurisdiction
- Culture is the principal source of the validity of a moral right or rule
Show Solution
Verified By Collegedunia
The Correct Option is D
Solution and Explanation
Step 1: Relativism spectrum.
- Universalism: HR valid everywhere (option b).
- Strong cultural relativism: culture is the principal source of moral validity, though a few universal minima may exist.
- Radical/absolute relativism: culture the sole source (option a — too extreme).
Step 2: Evaluate options.
(a) Overstates to “sole”; captures radical relativism.
(c) Ties HR to municipal law positivism, not cultural relativism per se.
Hence (d) best represents strong cultural relativism. \[ \boxed{(d)} \]
- Universalism: HR valid everywhere (option b).
- Strong cultural relativism: culture is the principal source of moral validity, though a few universal minima may exist.
- Radical/absolute relativism: culture the sole source (option a — too extreme).
Step 2: Evaluate options.
(a) Overstates to “sole”; captures radical relativism.
(c) Ties HR to municipal law positivism, not cultural relativism per se.
Hence (d) best represents strong cultural relativism. \[ \boxed{(d)} \]
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Top AILET PhD Legal Studies Questions
- Which of the following condition must be satisfied for invoking Section 210 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, in a case?
- Assertion (A) : The rule making power of the Supreme Court is not subject to any law made by the Parliament of India.
Reason (R) : Only an impartial and independent judiciary can protect the right of the individual without fear or favour. - Roscoe Pound’s theory identifies the proper goal of a legal system as the satisfaction of demands, desires, and claims. The demands, desires, and claims are called as
- Which of the following is not correct regarding a person arrested with or without warrant by a police officer or under a warrant by a private person?
- “What cannot be done directly, cannot be done indirectly”– this statement epitomises the doctrine of
View More Questions
Top AILET PhD Human Rights Law Questions
- In which case, it was held by the Supreme Court that an anticipatory bail cannot be limited or restricted to a fixed period ?
- Which instrument is not a core international human rights instrument ?
- Jus cogens norm indicates
- Which human rights are often understood as the third-generation rights ?
- Which proposition most appropriately captures the notion of strong cultural relativism approach to human rights ?
View More Questions
Top AILET PhD Questions
- Which of the following plays of Shaw is based on the story of a flower girl named Eliza Dolittle?
- By which pen name did Mary Ann Evans write?
- With which country can the city of Troy be identified in modern times?
- In Greek mythology, where is the seat of the King of Gods, Zeus?
- Which popular film was made on a novel in English by R.K. Narayan?
View More Questions