Question:
Which one of the following options is challenged by G. E. Moore’s ‘Open Question Argument’ concerning meta-ethical positions?
Which one of the following options is challenged by G. E. Moore’s ‘Open Question Argument’ concerning meta-ethical positions?
Show Hint
Moore's argument doesn't just reject natural definitions of "good" — it also applies to supernatural definitions. Any attempt to define "good" makes it vulnerable to the open question challenge.
Updated On: Apr 26, 2025
- Naturalism but not Supernaturalism
- Supernaturalism but not Naturalism
- Both Naturalism and Supernaturalism
- Neither Naturalism nor Supernaturalism
Show Solution
Verified By Collegedunia
The Correct Option is C
Solution and Explanation
Step 1: Understand the Open Question Argument.
G. E. Moore’s Open Question Argument posits that for any proposed definition of "good" (e.g., pleasure, will of God), it is always an open and meaningful question to ask, “But is that really good?” Hence, "good" is indefinable.
Step 2: Identify the meta-ethical positions under challenge.
Ethical Naturalism (e.g., defining good as pleasure) is directly challenged.
Ethical Supernaturalism (e.g., defining good as the will of God) is also challenged, since it too tries to define "good" in terms of something else.
Thus, Moore's argument challenges both naturalistic and supernaturalistic accounts of morality.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Top GATE XH- C4 Classical and Modern Western Philosophy Questions
- Amma’s tone in the context of the given passage is that of: it{For Amma, the difference between men and women was a kind of discrimination and inequality; she felt strongly about women’s rights but was not familiar with concepts like gender and patriarchy. She would have dismissed Betty Friedan because she was predominantly dealing with the problems of white middle-class women in the United States. Amma, and women of her generation, could de-link the oppression of women from the wider struggle for the liberation of human beings from class exploitation and imperialism. So Amma continued to play her role as mother and wife, but would often complain: ‘I am a doormat on which everyone wipes their emotional dirt off.’}
- Fill in the blanks by choosing the correct sequence for the following passage: it{I am wearing for the first time some (i) \_\_\_\_\_\_ that I have never been able to wear for long at a time, as they are horribly tight. I usually put them on just before giving a lecture. The painful pressure they exert on my feet goads my oratorical capacities to their utmost. This sharp and overwhelming pain makes me sing like a nightingale or like one of those Neapolitan singers who also wear (ii) \_\_\_\_\_\_ that are too tight. The visceral physical longing, the overwhelming torture provoked by my (iii) \_\_\_\_\_\_, forces me to extract from words distilled and sublime truths, generalized by the supreme inquisition of the pain my (iv) \_\_\_\_\_\_ suffer.}
- The appropriate synonym for the word ‘ignite’ in the following passage will be: it{Spirituality must be integrated with education. Self-realization is the focus. Each one of us must become aware of our higher self. We are links of a great past to a grand future. We should ignite our dormant inner energy and let it guide our lives. The radiance of such minds embarked on constructive endeavor will bring peace, prosperity, and bliss to this nation.}
- Which of the following sentences is punctuated correctly?
- Fill in the blanks with the correct combination of tenses for the given sentence: it{Darwin’s work (i) \_\_\_\_\_\_ a related effect that (ii) \_\_\_\_\_\_ influenced the development of environmental politics – a ‘decentering’ of the human being.}
View More Questions
Top GATE XH- C4 Philosophy Questions
- Amma’s tone in the context of the given passage is that of: it{For Amma, the difference between men and women was a kind of discrimination and inequality; she felt strongly about women’s rights but was not familiar with concepts like gender and patriarchy. She would have dismissed Betty Friedan because she was predominantly dealing with the problems of white middle-class women in the United States. Amma, and women of her generation, could de-link the oppression of women from the wider struggle for the liberation of human beings from class exploitation and imperialism. So Amma continued to play her role as mother and wife, but would often complain: ‘I am a doormat on which everyone wipes their emotional dirt off.’}
- Fill in the blanks by choosing the correct sequence for the following passage: it{I am wearing for the first time some (i) \_\_\_\_\_\_ that I have never been able to wear for long at a time, as they are horribly tight. I usually put them on just before giving a lecture. The painful pressure they exert on my feet goads my oratorical capacities to their utmost. This sharp and overwhelming pain makes me sing like a nightingale or like one of those Neapolitan singers who also wear (ii) \_\_\_\_\_\_ that are too tight. The visceral physical longing, the overwhelming torture provoked by my (iii) \_\_\_\_\_\_, forces me to extract from words distilled and sublime truths, generalized by the supreme inquisition of the pain my (iv) \_\_\_\_\_\_ suffer.}
- The appropriate synonym for the word ‘ignite’ in the following passage will be: it{Spirituality must be integrated with education. Self-realization is the focus. Each one of us must become aware of our higher self. We are links of a great past to a grand future. We should ignite our dormant inner energy and let it guide our lives. The radiance of such minds embarked on constructive endeavor will bring peace, prosperity, and bliss to this nation.}
- Which of the following sentences is punctuated correctly?
- Fill in the blanks with the correct combination of tenses for the given sentence: it{Darwin’s work (i) \_\_\_\_\_\_ a related effect that (ii) \_\_\_\_\_\_ influenced the development of environmental politics – a ‘decentering’ of the human being.}
View More Questions
Top GATE XH- C4 Questions
- If ‘—’ denotes increasing order of intensity, then the meaning of the words [simmer — seethe — smolder] is analogous to [break — raze — ]. Which one of the given options is appropriate to fill the blank?
- In a locality, the houses are numbered in the following way: The house-numbers on one side of a road are consecutive odd integers starting from 301, while the house-numbers on the other side of the road are consecutive even numbers starting from 302. The total number of houses is the same on both sides of the road. If the difference of the sum of the house-numbers between the two sides of the road is 27, then the number of houses on each side of the road is:
- For positive integers \( p \) and \( q \), with \( \frac{p}{q} \neq 1 \), \[ \left(\frac{p}{q}\right)^{\frac{p}{q}} = \left(\frac{p}{q}\right)^{(\frac{p}{q} - 1)}. \] Then: (1) \( q^p = p^q \)
- Which one of the given options is a possible value of \( X \) in the following sequence? \[ 3, 7, 15, X, 63, 127, 255 \]
- On a given day, how many times will the second-hand and the minute-hand of a clock cross each other during the clock time 12:05:00 hours to 12:55:00 hours?
View More Questions