Question:

Directions for questions: Each question has a set of four statements. Each statement has three segments. Choose the alternative where the third segment in the statement can be logically deduced using both the preceding two, but not just from one of them.

A. Many singers are not writers. All poets are singers. Some poets are not writers.
B. Giants climb beanstalks. Some chicken do not climb beanstalks. Some chicken are not giants.
C. All explorers live in snowdrifts. Some penguins live in snowdrifts. Some penguins are explorers.
D. Amar is taller than Akbar. Anthony is shorter than Amar. Akbar is shorter than Anthony.

Show Hint

For each statement ask whether the group named in the third segment is really forced by both premises. Be careful with the 'some' premises and with the height comparison.
Updated On: Nov 4, 2026
  • A only
  • B and C
  • B only
  • D only
Show Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is C

Solution and Explanation

Step 1: Statement A:
Many singers are not writers, and all poets are singers. The poets could be among the singers who are writers. So 'Some poets are not writers' does not follow. A fails.

Step 2: Statement B:
All giants climb beanstalks. Some chicken do not climb beanstalks, so those chicken cannot be giants. Hence 'Some chicken are not giants' follows, and both segments are used. B works.

Step 3: Statement C:
All explorers live in snowdrifts, but not everything that lives in snowdrifts is an explorer. The penguins who live in snowdrifts may not be explorers. C fails.

Step 4: Statement D:
Akbar is shorter than Amar, and Anthony is shorter than Amar. Both are shorter than Amar, but their heights relative to each other are not known. 'Akbar is shorter than Anthony' does not follow. D fails.

Step 5: Match with the options:
Only B is valid.

Final Answer:
The correct option is (3): B only
Was this answer helpful?
0
0

Top CAT Data Interpretation & Logical Reasoning (DILR) Questions

View More Questions

Top CAT Sentence Arrangement Questions

View More Questions