Step 1: Concept Electron affinity is the energy released when an electron is added to a neutral atom.
Step 2: Meaning While electron affinity usually decreases down a group, the first element of a group often shows an anomaly.
Step 3: Analysis Oxygen has a very small atomic size. When an electron is added, it experiences significant inter-electronic repulsion from the electrons already present in the compact $n=2$ shell. Sulfur, being larger, accommodates the incoming electron more easily with less repulsion.
Step 4: Conclusion Therefore, Sulfur has a higher electron affinity than Oxygen, and it is the highest in Group 16.
Final Answer: (B)