Principle: Negligence may be inferred when the incident causing harm is of a kind that ordinarily does not occur without someone’s negligence, the instrumentality or control that caused the harm was under the defendant’s management, and the plaintiff did not contribute to the harm.
Fact: Anita visits a hospital for a routine check-up. While waiting in the lobby, a large ceiling fan suddenly detaches and falls, injuring her shoulder. The hospital authorities claim that the fan had been regularly serviced and no defect was known before the accident.
Applying only the given principle to the fact, is the hospital liable? Select the most appropriate option: