Question:

Choose the set in which the third statement logically follows from the first two.

A. Dogs sleep in the open.
B. Sheep sleep indoors.
C. Dogs are like sheep.
D. All indoors are sheep.
E. Some dogs are not sheep.
F. Some open are not sheep.

Show Hint

"Sleeping in the open" and "sleeping indoors" cannot be true of the same animal at the same time. See what that says about dogs and sheep.
Updated On: Nov 4, 2026
  • ABE
  • DCA
  • AFE
  • None of these
Show Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is A

Solution and Explanation

Step 1: Understand the statements:
A says dogs sleep in the open. B says sheep sleep indoors. Something that sleeps in the open does not sleep indoors.

Step 2: Test set (1) ABE:
Dogs sleep in the open and sheep sleep indoors, so dogs cannot be sheep. In particular, some dogs are not sheep, which is E. Valid.

Step 3: Test the other sets:
Set (3) AFE: A: Dogs sleep in the open. F: Some open are not sheep. The "open" which are not sheep may not be the dogs, so E does not follow.
Set (2) DCA: D: All indoors are sheep. C: Dogs are like sheep. Being "like" sheep does not mean sleeping in the open, so A does not follow.
Since set (1) is valid, "None of these" is wrong.

Final Answer:
The correct option is (1): ABE
Was this answer helpful?
0
0

Top CAT Verbal Ability & Reading Comprehension (VARC) Questions

View More Questions

Top CAT Syllogism Questions

View More Questions