Question:
Statement: Should smoking be completely banned in all public places in the country? Argument I: Yes, it protects non-smokers from the harmful effects of passive smoking. Argument II: No, it violates the personal freedom of individuals to smoke wherever they wish.
Statement: Should smoking be completely banned in all public places in the country? Argument I: Yes, it protects non-smokers from the harmful effects of passive smoking. Argument II: No, it violates the personal freedom of individuals to smoke wherever they wish.
Show Hint
Judge each argument on whether it is directly relevant to the policy question and backed by a specific, realistic reason, not just a general principle.
Updated On: Jul 8, 2026
- Only argument I is strong
- Only argument II is strong
- Both arguments are strong
- Neither argument is strong
Show Solution
Verified By Collegedunia
The Correct Option is A
Solution and Explanation
Argument I is strong because protecting the health of non-smokers in shared public spaces is a substantial, directly relevant public-interest reason. Argument II is weak because personal freedom does not extend to harming others in public places, so it does not outweigh the health concern. Only argument I is strong. The correct option is 'Only argument I is strong'.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Top NMAT Data Interpretation & Logical Reasoning (DILR) Questions
- The following table gives the population of a town from 2017 to 2021. Some data is missing from it. What is the number of children in 2018?
The table below provides the population details for men, women, and children over the years from 2017 to 2021. Some data is missing. The total population and the increase or decrease over the preceding year are also provided.
- The following table gives the population of a town from 2017 to 2021. Some data is missing from it. How much is the increase or decrease of population in 2021 over 2020?
The table below provides the population details for men, women, and children over the years from 2017 to 2021. Some data is missing. The total population and the increase or decrease over the preceding year are also provided. - The following table gives the population of a town from 2017 to 2021. Some data is missing from it. The percentage change in the population in 2020 with respect to 2018 is:
The table below provides the population details for men, women, and children over the years from 2017 to 2021. Some data is missing. The total population and the increase or decrease over the preceding year are also provided. - The following chart shows the percentage of students studying in different IITs in the year 2022. The ratio of male students to female students in each IIT is given. What is the total number of male students in all IITs put together?
The table below shows the percentage of students in different IITs, along with the ratio of male to female students in each IIT. - The following chart shows the percentage of students studying in different IITs in the year 2022. The ratio of male students to female students in each IIT is given. The number of female students in IIT Kanpur is what percent of the total number of students in it?
The table below shows the percentage of students in different IITs, along with the ratio of male to female students in each IIT.
View More Questions
Top NMAT Statements and Arguments Questions
- Statement: Should there be a strict upper age limit for candidates appearing in government job examinations? Argument I: No, age has nothing to do with a person's ability to do a job. Argument II: Yes, it ensures a steady inflow of younger people into the workforce and gives fair opportunity across generations.
- Statement: Should all college students be required to complete a mandatory internship before graduation? Argument I: No, students in some fields may find it very hard to secure a relevant internship, which could delay their graduation. Argument II: Yes, it gives students practical work experience that improves their employability.
Top NMAT Questions
- Vineet calculates his profit percentage on the selling price whereas Roshan calculates his profit on the cost price. They find that the difference of their profits is Rs. 275. If the selling price of both of them are the same, and Vineet gets 25\(\%\) profit and Roshan gets 15\(\%\) profit, then find their selling price.
- A man sells two horses for Rs. 1475. The cost price of the first is equal to the selling price of the second. If the first is sold at 20\(\%\) loss and the second at 25\(\%\) gain, what is his total gain or loss (in rupees)?
- A farmer sold a cow and an ox for Rs. 800 and got a profit of 20\(\%\) on the cow and 25\(\%\) on the ox. If he sells the cow and the ox for Rs. 820 and gets a profit of 25\(\%\) on the cow and 20\(\%\) on the ox, the individual cost price of the cow and the ox is
- Arun borrowed a sum of money from Jayant at the rate of 8\(\%\) per annum simple interest for the first four years, 10\(\%\) per annum for the next 6 years and 12\(\%\) per annum for the period beyond 10 yerras. If he pays a total of Rs. 12,160 as interest only at the end of 15 years, how much money did he borrow?
- A sum of Rs. 1,440 is lent out in three parts in such a way that the interests on first part at 2\(\%\) for 3 years, second part at 3\(\%\) for 4 years and third part at 4\(\%\) for 5 years are equal. Then the difference between the largest and the smallest sum is
View More Questions