Question:

Para-Summary Paragraph: 
Public debates often oversimplify complex issues into binary choices such as right/wrong or safe/unsafe. This reductive framing limits nuanced thinking, discourages dialogue, and pushes people to defend positions rather than understand diverse viewpoints. 

Which sentence best summarizes this paragraph? 

  1. Public debates today have become unnecessarily aggressive. 
  2. Oversimplifying issues into binaries prevents meaningful discussion.
  3. People avoid nuanced thinking due to lack of education. 
  4. Complex issues should always involve experts. 

Show Hint

A good summary captures the core idea without adding examples, opinions, or details. Look for the option that expresses the paragraph's main claim in the most concise form.
Updated On: Jul 4, 2026
Show Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

Approach Solution - 1

Approach: A para-summary must carry the paragraph's main claim AND its consequence \(--\) not a side detail, not an exaggeration. Find the cause-and-effect spine, then match.

Step 1: Spine of the paragraph. Cause: public debate reduces complex issues to binaries (right/wrong, safe/unsafe). Effect: this limits nuanced thinking, discourages dialogue, and pushes people to defend rather than understand. So the core is "binary framing harms meaningful discussion."

Step 2: Match. Option 2 \(--\) "Oversimplifying issues into binaries prevents meaningful discussion" \(--\) captures both the cause (binaries) and the effect (discussion suffers). It is the whole paragraph in one line.

Step 3: Eliminate. Option 1 ("debates have become aggressive") is a distortion \(--\) the paragraph never says aggression. Option 3 ("due to lack of education") invents a cause the paragraph never gives. Option 4 ("should always involve experts") is out of scope and prescriptive, while the paragraph is descriptive.

Best summary: \( \text{Option 2} \)
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Show Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

Approach Solution -2

Approach (scope-fit test): A correct summary must cover the paragraph exactly, not part of it, not more than it. Check each option for narrowing (keeping only a detail) or broadening (adding a claim the paragraph never makes), and keep the one that fits like a glove.

The paragraph's full scope is: binary framing (cause) reduces nuanced thinking and discourages dialogue (effect). Option 1 narrows the scope to “aggression,” a detail the paragraph never states. Option 3 narrows further, inventing “lack of education” as a cause that is nowhere in the text. Option 4 broadens the scope into a prescription (“should always involve experts”), turning a descriptive observation into advice the author never gives. Option 2, “oversimplifying issues into binaries prevents meaningful discussion,” covers exactly the cause and exactly the effect stated, no more, no less.

Best summary: Option 2.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0

Top CAT Verbal Ability & Reading Comprehension (VARC) Questions

View More Questions

Top CAT Para Summary Questions

View More Questions