Question:

If the equation \( x^{3} - ax^{2} + bx - a = 0 \) has three real roots, then it must be the case that,

Show Hint

Use the relations between roots and coefficients: the sum and the product of the roots are both equal to a. Then look at \((1 + ip)(1 + iq)(1 + ir)\).
Updated On: Nov 4, 2026
  • \( b \ne 1 \)
  • \( b = 1 \)
  • \( a = 1 \)
  • \( a \ne 1 \)
Show Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is A

Solution and Explanation

Step 1: Roots and coefficients:
Let the real roots be \(p, q, r\). Then \(p + q + r = a\), \(pq + qr + rp = b\) and \(pqr = a\). In particular \(p + q + r = pqr\).

Step 2: A product of complex numbers:
Expand \((1 + ip)(1 + iq)(1 + ir) = 1 - (pq + qr + rp) + i\,[(p + q + r) - pqr] = (1 - b) + i \cdot 0 = 1 - b\).

Step 3: Take absolute values:
The modulus of the left side is \(\sqrt{(1+p^2)(1+q^2)(1+r^2)} \ge 1\) because each factor \(1 + p^2 \ge 1\) for real p. So \(|1 - b| \ge 1\), which gives \(b \ne 1\).

Step 4: Other options:
The cubic \(x^3 - x\) (roots \(0, 1, -1\)) has \(a = 0, b = -1\), so \(a = 1\) is not forced. The cubic with roots \(3\) and \(-1 \pm \sqrt{2/3}\) has \(a = 3 - 2 = 1\) and \(pqr = 3\left(1 - \tfrac{2}{3}\right) = 1 = a\), so \(a \ne 1\) is not forced either. Only \(b \ne 1\) must hold.

Final Answer:
The correct option is (1): \( b \ne 1 \)
Was this answer helpful?
0
0

Top CAT Quantitative Aptitude Questions

View More Questions