Question:

Given below are six statements followed by sets of three. Mark the option in which the statements are most logically related.
1. Some crows are flies
2. Some flies are mosquitoes
3. All mosquitoes are flies
4. Some owls are flies
5. All owls are mosquitoes
6. Some mosquitoes are not owls

Show Hint

Take 'All owls are mosquitoes' and 'Some owls are flies' together and ask what they say about flies and mosquitoes.
Updated On: Nov 5, 2026
  • 542
  • 356
  • 145
  • 123
Show Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is A

Solution and Explanation

Step 1: Test option (1): statements 5, 4, 2:
Statement 5: All owls are mosquitoes. Statement 4: Some owls are flies. Pick those owls that are flies. They are owls, so they are mosquitoes (by 5). So there are things that are both flies and mosquitoes: some flies are mosquitoes (statement 2). This follows.

Step 2: Test the other options:
Option (4), 1-2-3: 'some crows are flies' and 'some flies are mosquitoes' prove nothing about 'all mosquitoes are flies'. Option (2), 3-5-6: 'all mosquitoes are flies' and 'all owls are mosquitoes' give 'all owls are flies', not 'some mosquitoes are not owls'. Option (3), 1-4-5: 'some crows are flies' and 'some owls are flies' give nothing about 'all owls are mosquitoes'.

Step 3: Conclude:
Only 5-4-2 is a valid argument.

Final Answer:
The correct option is (1): 542
Was this answer helpful?
0
0

Top CAT Verbal Ability & Reading Comprehension (VARC) Questions

View More Questions

Top CAT Syllogism Questions

View More Questions