Choose the set in which the statements are most logically related.
A. All men are men of scientific ability. B. Some women are women of scientific ability. C. Some men are men of artistic genius. D. Some men and women are of scientific ability. E. All men of artistic genius are men of scientific ability. F. Some women of artistic genius are women of scientific ability.
Show Hint
A set is logically related when two of its statements, taken as premises, force the third statement as a conclusion (a valid syllogism). Test each option that way.
Step 1: Understand the task: Find the set whose statements are all about the same group and are connected by one following from another.
Step 2: Test option (B) ACE: A: All men have scientific ability. So any subset of men, in particular the men of artistic genius mentioned in C, also has scientific ability. This gives E: all men of artistic genius are men of scientific ability. So E follows from A (and C supplies the group of artistic men that E talks about). All three statements are about men and are consistent and linked.
Step 3: Check the others: (A) ACD: D speaks of women as well, which nothing in A or C supports. (C) DEF: D, E and F mix men and women; none follows from the other two. (D) ABC: B is about women and has no link with A and C, so the set is not related.