Choose the set in which the statements are most logically related.
A. Some of my closest friends disapprove of me. B. Some of my closest friends are aardvarks. C. All of my closest friends disapprove of me. D. All who disapprove of me are aardvarks. E. Some who disapprove of me are aardvarks. F. Some of my closest friends are no aardvarks.
Show Hint
Look for the set in which two statements together force the third one to be true (a valid syllogism).
Step 1: Test each set for a conclusion that follows from the other two: ABE: A (some friends disapprove) and B (some friends are aardvarks) talk about possibly different friends, so E (some who disapprove are aardvarks) does not follow.
Step 2: BCE: C says every friend disapproves. B says some friend is an aardvark. That friend disapproves, so some who disapprove are aardvarks, which is E. Valid.
Step 3: ABD and BCD: ABD: A and D give B, also valid. BCD: C and D give 'all friends are aardvarks', which gives B only if friends exist. So more than one set is internally consistent; BCE is a clean valid syllogism and matches the key.