Phosphorus, in its most stable allotrope, exists as a P₄ molecule, meaning it consists of four phosphorus atoms. Therefore, the atomicity of phosphorus is 4. The molecular structure of phosphorus involves a tetrahedral arrangement of phosphorus atoms in the P₄ molecule, which is the form most commonly encountered in nature.
Phosphorus's atomicity depends on the structure its atoms settle into when they bond together, so it helps to think about how phosphorus atoms actually bond rather than just recalling the number.
Working through how the atoms actually bond together shows that four phosphorus atoms fit together into a stable, evenly bonded tetrahedral cluster, while 2, 3, or 5 atoms cannot form a stable arrangement.
Therefore, the correct answer is 4.