Comprehension

At first sight, it looks as though panchayati raj, the lower layer of federalism in our polity, is as firmly entrenched in our system as is the older and higher layer comprising the Union Government and the State. Like the democratic institutions at the higher level, those at the panchayat level, the panchayati raj institutions (PRIs), are written into and protected by the Constitution. All the essential features, which distinguish a unitary system from a federal one, are as much enshrined at the lower as at the upper level of our federal system. But look closely and you will discover a fatal flaw. The letter of the Constitution as well as the spirit of the present polity have exposed the intra-State level of our federal system to a dilemma of which the inter-State and Union-State layers are free. The flaw has many causes. But all of them are rooted in an historical anomaly, that while the dynamics of federalism and democracy have given added strength to the rights given to the States in the Constitution, they have worked against the rights of panchayats.

At both levels of our federal system there is the same tussle between those who have certain rights and those who try to encroach upon them if they believe they can. Thus, the Union Government was able to encroach upon certain rights given to the States by the Constitution. It got away with that because the single dominant party system, which characterised Centre-State relations for close upon two decades, gave the party in power at the Union level many extra-constitutional political levers. Second, the Supreme Court had not yet begun to extend the limits of its power. But all that has changed in recent times. The spurt given to a multi-party democracy by the overthrow of the Emergency in 1977 became a long-term trend later on because of the ways in which a vigorously democratic multi-party system works in a political society which is as assertively pluralistic as Indian society is. It gives political clout to all the various segments which constitute that society. Secondly, because of the linguistic reorganisation of States in the 1950s, many of the most assertive segments have found their most assertive expression as States. Thirdly, with single-party dominance becoming a thing of the past at the Union level, governments can be formed at that level only by multi-party coalitions in which State-level parties are major players. This has made it impossible for the Union Government to do much about anything unless it also carries a sufficient number of State-level parties with it. Indian federalism is now more real than it used to be, but an unfortunate side-effect is that India’s panchayati raj system, inaugurated with such fanfare in the early 1980s, has become less real.

By the time the PRIs came on the scene, most of the political space in our federal system had been occupied by the Centre in the first 30 years of Independence, and most of what was still left after that was occupied by the States in the next 20. PRIs might have hoped to wrest some space from their immediate neighbour, the States, just as the States had wrested some from the Centre. But having at last managed to checkmate the Centre’s encroachments on their rights, the States were not about to allow the PRIs to do some encroaching of their own.

By the 1980’s and early 1990s, the only nationally left, the Congress, had gone deeper into a siege mentality. Finding itself surrounded by State-level parties, it had built walls against them in stead of winning them over. Next, the States retaliated by blocking Congress proposals for panchayati raj in Parliament, suspecting that the Centre would try to use panchayats to by-pass State Governments. The suspicion fed on the fact that the powers proposed by the Congress for panchayats were very similar to many of the more lucrative powers of State Governments. State-level leaders also feared, perhaps, that if panchayat-level leaders captured some of the larger PRIs, such as district-level panchayats, they would exert pressure on State-level leaders through intra-State multi-party federalism.

It soon became obvious to Congress leaders that there was no way the panchayati raj amendments they wanted to write into the Constitution would pass muster unless State-level parties were given their pound of flesh. The amendments were allowed only after it was agreed that the powers of panchayats could be listed in the Constitution. Illustratively, they would be defined and endowed on PRIs by the State Legislature acting at its discretion.

This left the door wide open for the States to exert the power of the new political fact that while the Union and State Governments could afford to ignore panchayats as long as the MLAs were happy, the Union Government had to be sensitive to the demands of State-level parties. This has given State-level actors strong beachheads on the shores of both inter-State and intra-State federalism. By using various administrative devices and non-elected parallel structures, State Governments have subordinated their PRIs to the State administration and given the upper hand to State Government officials against the elected heads of PRIs. Panchayats have become local agencies for implementing schemes drawn up in distant State capitals. And their own volition has been further circumscribed by a plethora of ‘Centrally-sponsored schemes’. These are drawn up by even more distant Central authorities but at the same time tie up local staff and resources on pain of the schemes being switched off in the absence of matching local contribution. The ‘foreign aid’ syndrome can be clearly seen at work behind this kind of ‘grass roots development’.

Question: 1

The central theme of the passage can be best summarized as

Show Hint

Ask what the whole passage argues: it begins with a "fatal flaw" in panchayati raj and then explains why panchayats lack real power.
Updated On: Nov 6, 2026
  • a truly federal polity has not developed since PRIs have not been allowed the necessary political space.
  • panchayati raj is firmly entrenched at the lower level of our federal system of governance.
  • our grassroots development at the panchayat level is now driven by the “foreign aid” syndrome.
  • the Union Government and State-level parties are engaged in a struggle for the protection of their respective.
Show Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is A

Solution and Explanation

Step 1: Trace the argument of the passage:
The passage opens by saying panchayati raj only seems as firmly entrenched as the Union and State levels, but has "a fatal flaw". The States gained rights from the Centre as federalism became real, but the same forces worked against panchayats. The States, having occupied the political space, did not allow PRIs to encroach on it, and State governments have subordinated PRIs through administrative devices.

Step 2: State the theme:
The central point is that, although federalism has become more real at the Union-State level, the panchayati raj level has been denied political space and has become less real. So a federal polity covering all levels has not truly developed.

Step 3: Check the options:
Option (3) is only a closing remark about Centrally-sponsored schemes. Option (2) is the first impression that the author immediately says is misleading. Option (4) is incomplete as printed and describes only the Union-State tussle, which is background. Option (1) covers the whole argument.

Final Answer:
The correct option is (1): a truly federal polity has not developed since PRIs have not been allowed the necessary political space.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Question: 2

The sentence in the last paragraph, "And their own volition has been further circumscribed . . ." refers to

Show Hint

Look for answers that focus on the centralization of power and how it impacts local decision-making autonomy.
Updated On: Jul 1, 2026
  • the weakening of the local institutions’ ability to plan according to their needs.
  • the increasing demands made on elected local leaders to match central grants with local contributions.
  • the empowering of the panchayat system as implementers of schemes from State capitals.
  • the process by which the prescribed Central schemes are reformulated by local elected leaders.
Show Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is A

Solution and Explanation

The passage discusses how the PRIs have lost the ability to act independently, being constrained by centrally-sponsored schemes that require matching local contributions. This weakens the local institutions. Therefore, the Correct Answer is: \[ \boxed{(1) \ \text{the weakening of the local institutions’ ability to plan according to their needs.}} \]
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Question: 3

What is the “dilemma” at the intra-State level mentioned in the first paragraph of the passage?

Show Hint

The first paragraph says the intra-State (panchayat) level faces a dilemma because the rights the Constitution gave to States were not matched for panchayats.
Updated On: Nov 6, 2026
  • Should the rights similar to those that the States managed to get be extended to panchayats as well?
  • Should the state governments wrest more space from the Union, before considering the panchayati system?
  • Should the single party system which has withered away be brought back at the level of the States?
  • Should the States get “their pound of flesh” before allowing the Union Government to pass any more laws?
Show Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is A

Solution and Explanation

Step 1: Read the first paragraph:
It says the intra-State level of the federal system faces "a dilemma of which the inter-State and Union-State layers are free". The cause is "an historical anomaly, that while the dynamics of federalism and democracy have given added strength to the rights given to the States in the Constitution, they have worked against the rights of panchayats."

Step 2: Turn it into a question:
The dilemma is therefore whether panchayats should also get rights similar to those that the States have obtained.

Step 3: Check the options:
Option (2) is about States taking more space from the Union, which is the Union-State layer, not the intra-State layer. Option (3) is about reviving a single-party system, which the passage treats as finished. Option (4) is about the States extracting a price in return for the panchayati raj amendments, which is a later event.

Final Answer:
The correct option is (1): Should the rights similar to those that the States managed to get be extended to panchayats as well?
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Question: 4

Which of the following most closely describes the ‘fatal flaw’ that the passage refers to?

Show Hint

Read the sentences just after 'you will discover a fatal flaw' and see what the flaw is said to be rooted in.
Updated On: Nov 6, 2026
  • The ways in which the democratic multi-party system works in an assertively pluralistic society like India’s are flawed.
  • The mechanisms that our federal system uses at the Union Government level to deal with States are imperfect.
  • The instruments that have ensured federalism at one level, have been used to achieve the opposite at another.
  • The Indian Constitution and the spirit of the Indian polity are fatally flawed.
Show Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is C

Solution and Explanation

Step 1: Find the flaw in the passage:
The first paragraph says the flaw is rooted in a historical anomaly: the dynamics of federalism and democracy have given added strength to the rights of the States in the Constitution, but they have worked against the rights of panchayats.

Step 2: Restate it:
The same forces (multi-party democracy, assertive States, coalition governments) that strengthened federalism between the Union and the States have weakened the panchayats, which form the lower layer of federalism.

Step 3: Check the options:
(1) The passage does not say that the multi-party democratic system is flawed.
(2) The flaw concerns the panchayat level, not the way the Union deals with States.
(3) The instruments that ensured federalism at the Union-State level have been used to achieve the opposite at the panchayat level. This matches the passage.
(4) The passage does not say that the Constitution and the polity are fatally flawed; it says that they have exposed the panchayat level to a dilemma.

Final Answer:
The correct option is (3): The instruments that have ensured federalism at one level, have been used to achieve the opposite at another.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Question: 5

Which of the following best captures the current state of Indian federalism as described in the passage?

Show Hint

The passage says "Indian federalism is now more real than it used to be". Ask what changed in how power is shared between the Union and the State-level parties.
Updated On: Nov 6, 2026
  • The Supreme Court has not begun to extend the limits of its power.
  • The multi-party system has replaced the single party system.
  • The Union, State and panchayati raj levels have become real.
  • There is real distribution of power between the Union and State-level parties.
Show Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is D

Solution and Explanation

Step 1: Find the description of current federalism:
The passage says: "Indian federalism is now more real than it used to be, but an unfortunate side-effect is that India’s panchayati raj system ... has become less real." It adds that the Union Government can do little unless it carries a sufficient number of State-level parties with it, and that it "has to be sensitive to the demands of State-level parties".

Step 2: Interpret it:
So at present the Union and the State-level parties genuinely share power. That is the real federalism the author describes, which comes at the cost of panchayati raj.

Step 3: Check the options:
Option (1) describes the past: the Supreme Court "had not yet begun" to extend its power, "but all that has changed". Option (3) is false, since panchayati raj has become less real. Option (2) is true as a political fact, but it is a cause of the change, not a description of the state of federalism. Option (4) states the present condition of federalism.

Final Answer:
The correct option is (4): There is real distribution of power between the Union and State-level parties.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0