Question:
A young adult sustains chest trauma with haemodynamic instability and bilateral femur and tibia fractures. Once the patient has been resuscitated and is haemodynamically stabilized, what is the most appropriate definitive management of the fractures?
(Figure: X-ray of the limb showing the long-bone fracture.)
A young adult sustains chest trauma with haemodynamic instability and bilateral femur and tibia fractures. Once the patient has been resuscitated and is haemodynamically stabilized, what is the most appropriate definitive management of the fractures?
(Figure: X-ray of the limb showing the long-bone fracture.)
(Figure: X-ray of the limb showing the long-bone fracture.)
Show Hint
Stabilized polytrauma: nail the femurs (gold standard), ex-fix the tibiae.
Updated On: Jun 25, 2026
- Intramedullary nailing of both femurs and external fixation of the tibiae
- Plating of the tibiae and external fixation of the femurs
- Nailing / plating / external fixation chosen by whichever procedure the surgeon can perform fastest
- External fixation of both femurs and both tibiae
Show Solution
Verified By Collegedunia
The Correct Option is A
Solution and Explanation
Step 1: Recognise the clinical setting.
A polytrauma patient with chest injury, haemodynamic instability and multiple long-bone fractures is at high risk for fat embolism, ARDS and the “second hit” of major surgery. Management follows damage-control orthopaedics (DCO) initially, then conversion to definitive fixation once the patient is physiologically stable.
Step 2: Apply the early-total-care vs damage-control principle.
The question specifies that the patient is already haemodynamically stabilized. A stable patient tolerates definitive fixation. For long-bone shaft fractures the definitive treatment of choice is intramedullary (IM) nailing, which gives early mobilisation, low infection rates and excellent union.
Step 3: Choose the correct fixation per bone.
• Femur shaft - closed IM nailing is the gold standard definitive treatment.
• Tibia - in a polytrauma patient who has just been stabilized, with chest injury and the systemic insult already sustained, the tibiae are best controlled with external fixation as a staged/definitive option, especially where soft-tissue status is uncertain.
This combination (nail the femurs, ex-fix the tibiae) prioritises the most beneficial procedure for the femoral fractures while limiting the surgical burden on the tibiae.
Step 4: Why the other options are wrong.
• Option 2 (plate tibia, ex-fix femur) - femoral shaft fractures are best nailed, not externally fixed, in a stable patient; plating tibia adds soft-tissue insult.
• Option 3 (fastest procedure by surgeon preference) - speed-based choice is a damage-control concept for an UNSTABLE patient; here the patient is stabilized, so definitive evidence-based fixation is indicated.
• Option 4 (ex-fix everything) - appropriate only as temporary damage control in an unstable patient, not as definitive care once stabilized.
Step 5: Key fact.
In a stabilized polytrauma patient, definitive care of femoral shaft fractures is IM nailing; the tibiae can be managed with external fixation - hence nailing of the femurs with external fixation of the tibiae.
A polytrauma patient with chest injury, haemodynamic instability and multiple long-bone fractures is at high risk for fat embolism, ARDS and the “second hit” of major surgery. Management follows damage-control orthopaedics (DCO) initially, then conversion to definitive fixation once the patient is physiologically stable.
Step 2: Apply the early-total-care vs damage-control principle.
The question specifies that the patient is already haemodynamically stabilized. A stable patient tolerates definitive fixation. For long-bone shaft fractures the definitive treatment of choice is intramedullary (IM) nailing, which gives early mobilisation, low infection rates and excellent union.
Step 3: Choose the correct fixation per bone.
• Femur shaft - closed IM nailing is the gold standard definitive treatment.
• Tibia - in a polytrauma patient who has just been stabilized, with chest injury and the systemic insult already sustained, the tibiae are best controlled with external fixation as a staged/definitive option, especially where soft-tissue status is uncertain.
This combination (nail the femurs, ex-fix the tibiae) prioritises the most beneficial procedure for the femoral fractures while limiting the surgical burden on the tibiae.
Step 4: Why the other options are wrong.
• Option 2 (plate tibia, ex-fix femur) - femoral shaft fractures are best nailed, not externally fixed, in a stable patient; plating tibia adds soft-tissue insult.
• Option 3 (fastest procedure by surgeon preference) - speed-based choice is a damage-control concept for an UNSTABLE patient; here the patient is stabilized, so definitive evidence-based fixation is indicated.
• Option 4 (ex-fix everything) - appropriate only as temporary damage control in an unstable patient, not as definitive care once stabilized.
Step 5: Key fact.
In a stabilized polytrauma patient, definitive care of femoral shaft fractures is IM nailing; the tibiae can be managed with external fixation - hence nailing of the femurs with external fixation of the tibiae.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Top INI CET Orthopedics Questions
- Neuropraxia (the mildest grade of nerve injury) is best described as:
- Neurapraxia is best described as:
- A young adult presents with chest trauma, haemodynamic instability and fractures of bilateral femur and tibia. After the patient has been resuscitated and rendered haemodynamically stable, what is the most appropriate definitive management of the long-bone fractures?
- What is the most likely cause of unilateral genu varum (bow-leg deformity of one leg) in a patient with a history of a previous injury to that limb?
(Figure: AP X-ray of both lower limbs showing bowing of one leg.) - An athlete presents with sudden pain in the back of the ankle after a push-off, with weakness of plantarflexion. Imaging suggests Achilles tendon rupture. Which of the following is the relevant clinical finding/sign for this condition?
(Figure: Sagittal fat-saturated ankle MRI showing discontinuity of the Achilles tendon.)
Top INI CET Questions
- Which of the following is the most common cause of acute pancreatitis?
- Which of the following conditions is most commonly associated with hypoparathyroidism?
- The drug of choice for treating acute gout flare is:
- Which of the following bacteria is the most common cause of community-acquired pneumonia?
- Which of the following is the hallmark of Type 1 Diabetes mellitus?
View More Questions