Question:
Soft Drink Manufacturer: Our new children's soft drink, RipeCal, is fortified with calcium. Since calcium is essential for developing healthy bones, drinking RipeCal regularly will help make children healthy.
Consumer Advocate: But RipeCal also contains large amounts of sugar, and regularly consuming large amounts of sugar is unhealthful, especially for children.
In responding to the soft drink manufacturer, the consumer advocate does which of the following?
Soft Drink Manufacturer: Our new children's soft drink, RipeCal, is fortified with calcium. Since calcium is essential for developing healthy bones, drinking RipeCal regularly will help make children healthy.
Consumer Advocate: But RipeCal also contains large amounts of sugar, and regularly consuming large amounts of sugar is unhealthful, especially for children.
In responding to the soft drink manufacturer, the consumer advocate does which of the following?
Consumer Advocate: But RipeCal also contains large amounts of sugar, and regularly consuming large amounts of sugar is unhealthful, especially for children.
In responding to the soft drink manufacturer, the consumer advocate does which of the following?
Show Hint
In analyzing arguments, distinguish between challenging a premise and challenging a conclusion. The advocate accepts the premise (calcium is good) but introduces a counter-premise (sugar is bad) to attack the final conclusion (the drink is healthy).
Updated On: Oct 1, 2025
- Challenges the manufacturer's claim about the nutritional value of calcium in children's diets
- Argues that the evidence cited by the manufacturer, when properly considered, leads to a conclusion opposite to that reached by the manufacturer.
- Implies that the manufacturer of a product is typically unconcerned with the nutritional value of that product.
- Questions whether a substance that is healthful when eaten in moderation can be unhealthful when eaten in excessive amounts.
- Presents additional facts that call into question the conclusion drawn by the manufacturer.
Show Solution
Verified By Collegedunia
The Correct Option is
Solution and Explanation
Step 1: Understanding the Concept:
This is a critical reasoning question that asks you to identify the rhetorical strategy used by the consumer advocate to counter the manufacturer's argument. We need to analyze the structure of both arguments.
Step 2: Detailed Explanation:
Manufacturer's Argument:
\begin{itemize} \item Premise: RipeCal contains calcium. \item Premise: Calcium helps make children healthy. \item Conclusion: Drinking RipeCal will help make children healthy. \end{itemize} Consumer Advocate's Response:
The advocate does not dispute the manufacturer's premises about calcium. Instead, the advocate introduces a new piece of information: RipeCal contains large amounts of sugar, which is unhealthful.
This additional fact about sugar directly challenges the manufacturer's overall conclusion that the drink is healthy. The advocate is arguing that even if the calcium part is beneficial, the negative effect of the sugar outweighs it, thus calling the conclusion into question.
Let's evaluate the options:
\begin{itemize} \item (A) The advocate does not challenge the value of calcium. \item (B) The advocate introduces new evidence (sugar), rather than re-interpreting the manufacturer's evidence (calcium). \item (C) The advocate's response is about the product itself, not the manufacturer's general concerns or motives. \item (D) The advocate's argument is about the presence of an unhealthful substance (sugar), not the excessive consumption of a healthful one. \item (E) This accurately describes the strategy. The advocate presents an "additional fact" (the high sugar content) to challenge the manufacturer's "conclusion" (that RipeCal is a healthy choice). \end{itemize} Step 3: Final Answer:
The consumer advocate's strategy is to introduce an additional, negative fact to undermine the manufacturer's positive conclusion.
This is a critical reasoning question that asks you to identify the rhetorical strategy used by the consumer advocate to counter the manufacturer's argument. We need to analyze the structure of both arguments.
Step 2: Detailed Explanation:
Manufacturer's Argument:
\begin{itemize} \item Premise: RipeCal contains calcium. \item Premise: Calcium helps make children healthy. \item Conclusion: Drinking RipeCal will help make children healthy. \end{itemize} Consumer Advocate's Response:
The advocate does not dispute the manufacturer's premises about calcium. Instead, the advocate introduces a new piece of information: RipeCal contains large amounts of sugar, which is unhealthful.
This additional fact about sugar directly challenges the manufacturer's overall conclusion that the drink is healthy. The advocate is arguing that even if the calcium part is beneficial, the negative effect of the sugar outweighs it, thus calling the conclusion into question.
Let's evaluate the options:
\begin{itemize} \item (A) The advocate does not challenge the value of calcium. \item (B) The advocate introduces new evidence (sugar), rather than re-interpreting the manufacturer's evidence (calcium). \item (C) The advocate's response is about the product itself, not the manufacturer's general concerns or motives. \item (D) The advocate's argument is about the presence of an unhealthful substance (sugar), not the excessive consumption of a healthful one. \item (E) This accurately describes the strategy. The advocate presents an "additional fact" (the high sugar content) to challenge the manufacturer's "conclusion" (that RipeCal is a healthy choice). \end{itemize} Step 3: Final Answer:
The consumer advocate's strategy is to introduce an additional, negative fact to undermine the manufacturer's positive conclusion.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Top GRE Verbal Reasoning Questions
- Some activists believe that because the health-care system has become increasingly ---- to those it serves, individuals must ---- bureaucratic impediments in order to develop and promote new therapies.
- The acts of vandalism that these pranksters had actually ---- were insignificant compared with those they had ---- but had not attempted.
- Though one cannot say that Michelangelo was an impractical designer, he was, of all nonprofessional architects known, the most ---- in that he was the least constrained by tradition or precedent.
- Before adapting to changes in values, many prefer to ----, to ---- the universally agreed-on principles that have been upheld for centuries.
- Although the records of colonial New England are ---- in comparison with those available in France or England, the records of other English colonies in America are even more ----.
View More Questions
Top GRE Critical Reasoning Questions
- Centuries ago, the Maya of Central America produced elaborate, deeply cut carvings in stone. The carvings would have required a cutting tool of hard stone or metal. Iron-ore deposits exist throughout Central America, but apparently the Maya never developed the technology to use them and the metals the Maya are known to have used, copper and gold, would not have been hard enough. Therefore, the Maya must have used stone tools to make these carvings.
Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument? - Electric washing machines, first introduced in the United States in 1925, significantly reduced the amount of time spent washing a given amount of clothes, yet the average amount of time households spent washing clothes increased after 1925. This increase is partially accounted for by the fact that many urban households had previously sent their clothes to professional laundries. But the average amount of time spent washing clothes also increased for rural households with no access to professional laundries.
Which of the following, if true, most helps to explain why the time spent washing clothes increased in rural areas? - As an example of the devastation wrought on music publishers by the photocopier, one executive noted that for a recent choral festival with 1,200 singers, the festival's organizing committee purchased only 12 copies of the music published by her company that was performed as part of the festival.
Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the support the example lends to the executive's contention that music publishers have been devastated by the photocopier? - For the past two years at FasCorp, there has been a policy to advertise any job opening to current employees and to give no job to an applicant from outside the company if a FasCorp employee applies who is qualified for the job. This policy has been strictly followed, yet even though numerous employees of FasCorp have been qualified for any given entry-level position, some entry-level jobs have been filled with people from outside the company.
If the information provided is true, which of the following must on the basis of it also be true about FasCorp during the past two years? - Counselor: Every year a popular newsmagazine publishes a list of United States colleges, ranking them according to an overall numerical score that is a composite of ratings according to several criteria. However, the overall scores generally should not be used by students as the basis for deciding to which colleges to apply.
Which of the following, if true, most helps to justify the counselor's recommendation?
View More Questions
Top GRE Questions
One pen costs \(\$\)0.25 and one marker costs \(\$\)0.35. At those prices, what is the total cost of 18 pens and 100 markers?
- Working alone at its constant rate, machine A produces kkk liters of a chemical in 10 minutes. Working alone at its constant rate, machine B produces kkk liters of the chemical in 15 minutes. How many minutes does it take machines A and B, working simultaneously at their respective constant rates, to produce kkk liters of the chemical?
- If the dollar amount of sales at Store P was $800,000 for 2006, what was the dollar amount of sales at that store for 2008?
- At Store T, the dollar amount of sales for 2007 was what percent of the dollar amount of sales for 2008? Give your answer to the nearest 0.1%.
- If the ratio of A to B is 3:4 and the ratio of B to C is 5:6, what is the ratio of A to C?
View More Questions