Question:
Raw materials based on which law creates certain rights and duties are called
Raw materials based on which law creates certain rights and duties are called
Show Hint
Remember that "facts" are the factual antecedents (ex facto ius oritur - law arises from facts).
In any legal problem, always identify the material facts first, as they are the trigger for the application of legal rules.
In any legal problem, always identify the material facts first, as they are the trigger for the application of legal rules.
Updated On: Jul 7, 2026
- Facts
- Judgments
- Documents
- All the above
Show Solution
Verified By Collegedunia
The Correct Option is A
Solution and Explanation
Step 1: Understanding the Question:
The question explores the fundamental building blocks of legal relationships.
It asks us to identify the "raw materials" from which the law creates rights and duties.
In legal theory, rights and duties do not exist in isolation.
They require a concrete basis to be recognized by the state.
Step 2: Key Concepts and Approach:
We must analyze the relationship between facts and the creation of legal rights.
A legal right or duty is always vested in a person by virtue of some underlying event or occurrence.
According to prominent jurists like John Salmond, facts are the source of all rights and duties.
Therefore, we need to evaluate which option represents these primary raw materials.
Step 3: Detailed Explanation:
• Facts as the Foundation: In legal theory, facts are the basic events or circumstances that the law recognizes as having legal consequences.
• Facts vs. Law: Law acts upon facts to generate legal consequences, which are expressed in the form of rights, duties, liabilities, or powers.
• Salmond's View: Salmond points out that the law must have some basis or facts upon which to operate. Without a factual matrix, no right can be claimed and no duty can be imposed.
• Role of Judgments: Judgments are decisions of the court that declare or enforce existing rights and duties based on proven facts. They are not the raw materials themselves.
• Role of Documents: Documents are merely evidence or instruments used to prove facts or record transactions. They represent facts but are not the raw materials in an abstract jurisprudential sense.
• Conclusion: Thus, facts are the fundamental raw materials that serve as the antecedent condition for the creation of any legal right or duty.
Step 4: Final Answer:
Hence, facts are the raw materials based on which law creates rights and duties.
The question explores the fundamental building blocks of legal relationships.
It asks us to identify the "raw materials" from which the law creates rights and duties.
In legal theory, rights and duties do not exist in isolation.
They require a concrete basis to be recognized by the state.
Step 2: Key Concepts and Approach:
We must analyze the relationship between facts and the creation of legal rights.
A legal right or duty is always vested in a person by virtue of some underlying event or occurrence.
According to prominent jurists like John Salmond, facts are the source of all rights and duties.
Therefore, we need to evaluate which option represents these primary raw materials.
Step 3: Detailed Explanation:
• Facts as the Foundation: In legal theory, facts are the basic events or circumstances that the law recognizes as having legal consequences.
• Facts vs. Law: Law acts upon facts to generate legal consequences, which are expressed in the form of rights, duties, liabilities, or powers.
• Salmond's View: Salmond points out that the law must have some basis or facts upon which to operate. Without a factual matrix, no right can be claimed and no duty can be imposed.
• Role of Judgments: Judgments are decisions of the court that declare or enforce existing rights and duties based on proven facts. They are not the raw materials themselves.
• Role of Documents: Documents are merely evidence or instruments used to prove facts or record transactions. They represent facts but are not the raw materials in an abstract jurisprudential sense.
• Conclusion: Thus, facts are the fundamental raw materials that serve as the antecedent condition for the creation of any legal right or duty.
Step 4: Final Answer:
Hence, facts are the raw materials based on which law creates rights and duties.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Top KLEE LLM Legal Studies Questions
- Source of law which consist in declaration of legal rules by a competent authority.
- Law is what the court has decided in respect of any particular set of facts, prior to such a decision , the opinion of lawyer is only a guess and this cannot be treated as law unless the court so decides by its judicial pronouncement. Consider the above observation and find which of the statement is correct?
- Consider the meaning of the maxim ‘cessante ratione legis cessat ipsa lex’ and see which of the following satisfies the essence of the maxim?
- Consider the following statements and identify which of the statements reflect the philosophy of Feminist school of thought?
- Core claim of realist is that judges respond primarily to the stimulus of fact. Whose proposition is this?
View More Questions
Top KLEE LLM Jurisprudence Questions
- Source of law which consist in declaration of legal rules by a competent authority.
- Law is what the court has decided in respect of any particular set of facts, prior to such a decision , the opinion of lawyer is only a guess and this cannot be treated as law unless the court so decides by its judicial pronouncement. Consider the above observation and find which of the statement is correct?
- Consider the meaning of the maxim ‘cessante ratione legis cessat ipsa lex’ and see which of the following satisfies the essence of the maxim?
- Consider the following statements and identify which of the statements reflect the philosophy of Feminist school of thought?
- Core claim of realist is that judges respond primarily to the stimulus of fact. Whose proposition is this?
View More Questions
Top KLEE LLM Questions
- Source of law which consist in declaration of legal rules by a competent authority.
- Law is what the court has decided in respect of any particular set of facts, prior to such a decision , the opinion of lawyer is only a guess and this cannot be treated as law unless the court so decides by its judicial pronouncement. Consider the above observation and find which of the statement is correct?
- Consider the meaning of the maxim ‘cessante ratione legis cessat ipsa lex’ and see which of the following satisfies the essence of the maxim?
- Consider the following statements and identify which of the statements reflect the philosophy of Feminist school of thought?
- Core claim of realist is that judges respond primarily to the stimulus of fact. Whose proposition is this?
View More Questions