Step 1: Lithium taken in the first trimester is a recognised cardiac teratogen.
Step 2: The classic association is Ebstein anomaly, a malformation in which the tricuspid valve is displaced downward into the right ventricle. This is a cardiac defect, so the broad category of congenital cardiac malformations is the most common lithium-related anomaly. Option A is correct.
Step 3: Neural tube defects are linked to valproate and carbamazepine, not lithium. Option B is wrong.
Step 4: Renal anomalies are not the characteristic teratogenic effect of lithium in the fetus, though lithium does affect adult kidneys. Option C is wrong.
Step 5: Fetal hydantoin syndrome is caused by phenytoin, not lithium. Option D is wrong.
Conclusion: The most common congenital anomaly with lithium is cardiac malformation, classically Ebstein anomaly, option A.