Question

Match the dialogues in (P–S) to the Gricean Maxim (i–v) that has been flouted to create humour. 

• A. P-(iii), Q-(i), R-(ii), S-(iv)
• B. P-(i), Q-(v), R-(ii), S-(iii)
• C. P-(i), Q-(iii), R-(iv), S-(v)
• D. P-(iv), Q-(ii), R-(iii), S-(i)

Hint:

Humour in conversation often arises when speakers intentionally flout Gricean Maxims rather than violate them outright.

Answer 1

The Correct Option is A

Step 1: Analyse dialogue P.
The response “Yes” provides less information than required and withholds the actual time. This flouts the Maxim of Quantity.
Step 2: Analyse dialogue Q.
The answer “Fish” is completely irrelevant to the question, thereby flouting the Maxim of Relation.
Step 3: Analyse dialogue R.
The reply is deliberately ambiguous and indirect, violating clarity and straightforwardness, hence flouting the Maxim of Manner.
Step 4: Analyse dialogue S.
The answer is factually questionable and ironic, thus flouting the Maxim of Quality.
Step 5: Conclusion.
The correct matching is P-(iii), Q-(i), R-(ii), S-(iv).