Question:

Each of the following questions contains six statements followed by four sets of combinations of three. Choose the set in which the combinations are logically related.
A. All roses have thorns.
B. All roses have nectar.
C. All plants with nectar have thorns.
D. All shrubs have roses.
E. All shrubs have nectar.
F. Some roses have thorns.

Show Hint

Find two statements that chain together (shrubs to roses to nectar) and check that the third is exactly their conclusion.
Updated On: Nov 5, 2026
  • BEF
  • BCF
  • ACF
  • BDE
Show Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is D

Solution and Explanation

Step 1: Look for a chain:
D says all shrubs have roses. B says all roses have nectar.

Step 2: Combine D and B:
Every shrub has roses, and every rose has nectar, so every shrub has nectar. That is exactly statement E.

Step 3: Check the other sets:
(1) BEF: nothing connects the shrubs in E to the roses in B and F.
(2) BCF: B and C give "all roses have thorns" (this is A), which is only a stronger form of F; F follows only if roses are assumed to exist, so it is a weaker fit than D, B, E.
(3) ACF: F is just a weaker form of A and C takes no part.

Final Answer:
The correct option is (4): BDE
Was this answer helpful?
0
0

Top CAT Data Interpretation & Logical Reasoning (DILR) Questions

View More Questions

Top CAT Logical Reasoning Questions

View More Questions