Question:

I. Refer to the dialogue between Daljeet and Avik in the chemistry lab. They have learnt about decomposition reactions. Who has understood decomposition reactions correctly? Justify your answer.
Daljeet: During a decomposition reaction, a substance decomposes to give two simpler compounds. \(\mathrm{MgCO_3}\) decomposes on heating to magnesium oxide and carbon dioxide.
Avik: No, during a decomposition reaction, a substance decomposes to give two elements. Water on electrolysis gives hydrogen and oxygen, both are elements.
II. Analyse the observations given in following two cases. Are these observations correct? Give reasons to support your answer.
(i) Iron fillings are added to an aqueous solution of magnesium sulphate.
Observation: The colourless solution turns greenish due to formation of iron sulphate.
(ii) Aluminium metal is added to dilute sulphuric acid
Observation: Brisk effervescence are seen due to evolution of a gas.

Show Hint

A decomposition starts from one compound and may give elements or compounds. Use the reactivity series for part II.
Updated On: Nov 3, 2026
Show Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

Solution and Explanation

Step 1: Recall what a decomposition reaction is:
In a decomposition reaction a single compound breaks down into two or more simpler substances. The products can be elements, compounds, or a mix of both. There is no rule that they must be two compounds or two elements.

Step 2: Part I: Check Daljeet:
Daljeet's example is correct. \(\mathrm{MgCO_3 \to MgO + CO_2}\) gives two compounds, so it is a decomposition.
But his general statement is incomplete. Products can also be elements, so he has understood only part of the idea.

Step 3: Part I: Check Avik:
Avik's example is correct. Electrolysis of water gives hydrogen and oxygen, which are elements, and it is also a decomposition.
But he is wrong to say the products must be two elements. Daljeet's example shows compounds can form too. So Avik has also understood only part of the idea.
Both students are partially correct.

Step 4: Part II (i): Iron and magnesium sulphate:
A more reactive metal displaces a less reactive metal from its salt solution. Magnesium is more reactive than iron.
So iron cannot displace magnesium from magnesium sulphate. No reaction takes place and the solution stays colourless. The observation is incorrect.

Step 5: Part II (ii): Aluminium and dilute sulphuric acid:
Aluminium reacts with dilute sulphuric acid and gives hydrogen gas.
\[ \mathrm{2Al + 3H_2SO_4 \to Al_2(SO_4)_3 + 3H_2} \]
Hydrogen is released as a few bubbles. Brisk effervescence is what we see when carbon dioxide is released, for example when a carbonate meets an acid. So the observation, as stated, is incorrect.

Final Answer:
Both Daljeet and Avik have partially understood decomposition. Observation (i) is incorrect because iron is less reactive than magnesium. Observation (ii) is incorrect because hydrogen gives only few bubbles; brisk effervescence is seen with carbon dioxide. \[ \boxed{\text{Both partially correct; (i) incorrect; (ii) incorrect}} \]
Was this answer helpful?
0
0

Top CBSE X Science Questions

View More Questions

Top CBSE X Questions

View More Questions