Step 1: Recall the meaning of the terms:
Oxidation is the gain of oxygen or loss of hydrogen (or electrons). Reduction is the loss of oxygen or gain of hydrogen (or electrons). A redox reaction is one in which oxidation and reduction happen together. One cannot occur without the other.
Step 2: Part I: Check Alisha:
In \(\mathrm{N_2 + 3H_2 \to 2NH_3}\), nitrogen gains hydrogen, so nitrogen is reduced. This part of her statement is true.
But hydrogen is oxidised in the same reaction (its oxidation number goes from 0 to +1). So the reaction is a redox reaction, not just a reduction. Alisha is only partly correct.
Step 3: Part I: Check Bhushan:
In rusting, iron combines with oxygen, so iron is oxidised. This is true.
But oxygen is reduced at the same time, so rusting is also a redox reaction. Bhushan is only partly correct.
Step 4: Part I: Check Drishti:
Drishti says both reactions are redox reactions. In ammonia formation nitrogen is reduced and hydrogen is oxidised. In rusting iron is oxidised and oxygen is reduced. So Drishti is fully correct.
Step 5: Part II (i): Correct the equation:
Errors: silver chloride is \(\mathrm{AgCl}\) (not \(\mathrm{AgCl_2}\), because Ag is +1 and Cl is -1). Magnesium nitrate is \(\mathrm{Mg(NO_3)_2}\) (not \(\mathrm{MgNO_3}\), because Mg is +2). The equation is also not balanced.
Atom count after correcting the formulae: Mg 1, Cl 2, Ag 1, N 2 on the right side but Ag 1 and N 1 on the left side. Put 2 before \(\mathrm{AgNO_3}\) and 2 before \(\mathrm{AgCl}\).
\[ \mathrm{MgCl_2 + 2AgNO_3 \to 2AgCl + Mg(NO_3)_2} \]
Step 6: Part II (ii): Correct the equation:
Errors: aluminium sulphate is \(\mathrm{Al_2(SO_4)_3}\) (Al is +3 and sulphate is -2). Also a metal reacting with a dilute acid gives hydrogen gas, not water.
Balance: 3 sulphate groups on the right need 3 \(\mathrm{H_2SO_4}\) on the left, and 2 Al atoms need 2 Al on the left. 3 \(\mathrm{H_2SO_4}\) give 6 H, so 3 \(\mathrm{H_2}\) are formed.
\[ \mathrm{2Al + 3H_2SO_4 \to Al_2(SO_4)_3 + 3H_2} \]
Final Answer:
Drishti is correct. Alisha and Bhushan are only partially correct because oxidation and reduction always go together. Corrected equations: (i) MgCl2 + 2AgNO3 gives 2AgCl + Mg(NO3)2; (ii) 2Al + 3H2SO4 gives Al2(SO4)3 + 3H2.
\[ \boxed{\text{Drishti};\ \mathrm{MgCl_2+2AgNO_3\to 2AgCl+Mg(NO_3)_2};\ \mathrm{2Al+3H_2SO_4\to Al_2(SO_4)_3+3H_2}} \]