Step 1: Macrocytosis with hypersegmented neutrophils points to a megaloblastic anemia, caused by either vitamin B12 or folate deficiency.
Step 2: Two extra clues separate the two. Paresthesia indicates neurological involvement (subacute combined degeneration), which is a feature of B12 deficiency, not folate deficiency.
Step 3: Atrophic gastritis destroys parietal cells, reducing intrinsic factor and impairing B12 absorption (pernicious anemia mechanism). This confirms B12, not folate, deficiency.
Conclusion: The picture of megaloblastic anemia plus neuropathy plus atrophic gastritis is vitamin B12 deficiency. Iron deficiency gives microcytic anemia, and riboflavin deficiency does not produce this picture.
Ref: Harrison's Principles of Internal Medicine.